How’s this for a totally not controversial article that won’t risk turning into a minefield at all? Today we’re going to dive into the question of whether men or women are more emotionally intelligent.
Fortunately, I am not doing this myself.
Instead, I talked with Jochen Menges, a professor of leadership at the University of Zurich in Switzerland and at the University of Cambridge in the UK, who has spent 20 years studying emotional intelligence.
Most recently, he’s co-author of a massive new meta-study in the journal Emotion, published by the American Psychological Association, that zeroed in on the specific question of whether women really are more emotionally intelligent than men.
This was a giant undertaking, synthesizing the findings of 1,279 academic articles comprising 609,278 participants from 76 countries over 3 decades.
The definition of emotional intelligence
Before we go any further — maybe we should define emotional intelligence? Then I’ll give you the results of the meta-study.
Menges and his colleagues — Mary Hausfeld from University of Limerick, Vera Hampel of the University of Zurich, and Leon Bach of the University of Zurich — used this definition in the paper: “recognition and use of one’s own and others’ emotional states to solve problems and regulate behaviour.”
And, when I interviewed him recently, Menges offered a slightly more bespoke definition: “To me, emotional intelligence is the ability to recognize, reason with and regulate emotions in oneself and others.”
No matter which definition you use, we start to see that emotional intelligence actually has at least two components: regulating and maybe leveraging your own emotions, and doing the same with other people’s emotions.
Not to overly foreshadow, but just perhaps — being good at one of the components doesn’t necessarily mean you’re also good at the other?
Three big findings
Sure enough, that’s part of the results of the meta-study. The three big findings:
First, according to performance-based tests, women are in fact more emotionally intelligent than men.
Second, however, if we were to go purely by self-observation, the differences in emotional intelligence between the sexes would almost entirely disappear. Basically, if you ask men and women if they think they’re emotionally intelligent, they’ll give you the same answers, on average.
“We do not know if in the self-report it’s the women who underestimate or whether it’s the men who overestimate,” Menges told me, “or whether it’s both.”
Finally, and this goes right to the “two components wrapped up in one definition” idea, women and men have different emotional strengths.
Women are generally better at understanding other people’s emotions according to the meta-study, while men are slightly better at regulating their own emotions.
Interestingly, I’m a man and I think I’m the exact opposite at this:
I’m pretty in tune with other people’s emotions. I think it’s either cause or effect of being the kind of person who just wants to understand as many other peopel as possible.
But, I’m probably less effective at regulating my own emotions. Mostly I have this natural tendency to go from euphroia to anxiety and back again based on whatever is the last thing I saw or heard — which at least I’m aware of and try hard to counteract.
So, I ran this stuff by Menges — especially what to do if you hear all this and think: Hmmm, I should probably be more emotionally intelligent, is there a way to fix that?
There are formal training programs, but we also just talked broadly about things anyone can practice day to day, including paying more attention to your emotions, and working to describe them accurately — then taking them into account when making decisions.
As a “word person,” so to speak, I like that advice.
“If I want to feel calm and I know that’s what I want, then I can just close my office door and I can get it, right?” Menges suggested. “But if I want to feel good, I don’t know what that means.”
Like a lot of things in life: fairly simple, but not at all easy.
But hey, at least we made it through the minefield!
Thank you for reading Understandably! If someone shared this with you, please sign up here for a free or paid subscription. I’m also grateful for one-off support (via Buy Me a Coffee) that helps me keep this whole thing going!
Other things worth knowing …
Fortune via Yahoo News: The Trump White House is starting to admit that your bank account and airline tickets are under attack from rogue AI.
Reuters via MSN: Contracts to purchase previously owned US homes plunged to a record low in October as higher mortgage rates suppressed demand for housing. The pending home sales index dropped 4.7% to 63.0 last month, the lowest level since the series started in 2001, the National Association of Realtors said on Wednesday. Economists polled by Reuters had forecast that contracts, which become sales after a month or two, would fall 2.0%. October marked the second straight month of large decreases.
NBC News: After leading Democrats back to the majority, Rep. Hakeem Jeffries of New York won his party’s nomination for speaker of the House in a closed-door, secret-ballot vote of 251-11, putting him on a glide path for election to the top job on the first day of the new Congress in January. Jeffries had faced grumbling from progressive members and activists calling for new and bolder leadership. But no challenger emerged.
Iowa Capital Dispatch: How it ends for defeated or retiring members of Congress. (This is actually a three year old article, but it’s relevant now, and I found it interesting.)
NYT: After nearly half a century in flight, NASA’s Voyager 1 spacecraft has crossed an invisible threshold — a boundary measured by time rather than distance. Today, our farthest-flung creation is one light-day from Earth, beaming messages home across an expanse that takes photons a full 24 hours to traverse. “It is truly a staggering feeling,,” said Nicky Fox, NASA’s associate administrator for the science mission directorate. “That makes us pause and think about just how vast our universe is.”
USA Today: For the next two weeks, Lander Allgood is using up his PTO – but not for a vacation away. He plans to lock in for the long-awaited release of Grand Theft Auto 6 on Thursday, Nov. 19. Allgood, a 26-year-old environmental specialist, represents one in five salaried workers in the United States who plan to take off work for the game’s release, as reported by human resources platform BambooHR. “We’re basically witnessing, I mean, the Apollo space program of video games,” Allgood said.
Hollywood Reporter: Six months of searching for the next James Bond, so many notable actors auditioning, endless media speculation and fan casting, and the winner is … that guy who’s in everything. Robert Pattinson is our seventh 007, and it’s rather tough to criticize Amazon MGM, producers and director Denis Villeneuve for selecting an actor who’s incredibly talented and has shown recent box office appeal.
Thanks for reading. Photo by Alonso Reyes on Unsplash. I wrote about some of this at Inc.com. See you in the comments!

I spent decades working with EQ, with four years leading the employee engagement team for USA Today. Even so, I never considered if there was a gender difference. Kudos for a great article leaving me with much to ponder!
When I saw the word “regulate” when it came to men I paused. Regulate is simply following a set of rules, something at which men do well. Just think of sports and the military. That is not EQ, which requires the “management” of emotions.
EQ is a hierarchy; you cannot effectively function at a higher level unless you have mastered the preceding levels. The levels are:
1. Self-awareness
2. Self-management (markedly different from regulate)
3. Social awareness (much like self-awareness but with others rather than yourself)
4. Relationship management
A helpful resource:
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6486483-emotional-intelligence-2-0
Covey’s 7 Habits of Highly Effective People dealt with the topic in a similar inner-dependent and inter-dependent manner. I highly recommend both books.
It is my belief that the majority of people never become fully self-aware, leading to issues of self-management and poor relationships.