Half as likely as Alaska
The Great Resignation, broken down by states. Also, 7 other things worth knowing today.
We’ve heard a lot recently about the Great Resignation. I’ve written about it myself. But until last week, I had assumed something that apparently was not true.
I had thought this was an American phenomenon; something taking place across the entire United States. I suspected that overall the odds of someone having left a job in, say, Alaska would have been roughly the same as in New York.
Then, out of nowhere, the folks at WalletHub came at me with a data compilation that leaves me scratching my head.
In short, they ranked the U.S. states (plus DC; can’t forget DC) by the percentage of workers who left their jobs—both in the most recent month for which data was available (I think January), and by last year as a whole. There were some surprises.
Here’s a link to their whole list. But for our purposes (so that this newsletter doesn’t run too long to open in most email clients, and also so I don’t completely violate copyright law), here are just the top 10 and bottom 10 states:
10 states with highest resignation rates in 2021:
Alaska, 3.98% of all workers quit their jobs during 2021
Nevada, 3.74%
Georgia, 3.66%
Kentucky, 3.43%
Hawaii, 3.41%
Mississippi, 3.39%
Montana, 3.33%
South Carolina, Wyoming, and Idaho, all tied for 8th at 3.28%
10 states with lowest resignation rates in 2021:
Maryland, 2.90%
Washington, DC, 2.60%
California, New Jersey, and Washington. State, all tied at 2.50%
Pennsylvania, 2.30%
Massachusetts, 2.20%
Connecticut, 2.20%
Minnesota, 2.10%
New York, 1.80%
Observations and questions
I wonder if you see some of the same things that I saw:
First off, there’s a much bigger disparity than I would have guessed. To use the example with which I started this newsletter, it turns out that an Alaskan worker was more than twice as likely to quit as a New Yorker during 2021.
Second, it’s not 100%, but you can’t help but notice that there are more “red” states at the top of the list (meaning workers were more likely to quit) and more “blue” states at the bottom (less likely). I almost didn’t want to include this observation since I try to keep politics out of this newsletter, but it’s pretty stark—especially on the “didn’t quit” end.
Finally, I tend to think of the low-quitting states as more urban (New York, Pennsylvania, California, New Jersey). Maybe the cost of living is higher, and people have less opportunity to quit? Although, a lot more Americans live in urban areas than maybe we tend to think; heck, even in Alaska, something like 40 percent of the population lives in Anchorage.
Anyway, I pored over these numbers, and as I tried without success to find a true pattern, I thought: Why not do the easy thing? Why not ask the readers?
We’ve now proven that I can mention almost any place in the U.S. or Canada and find that we have at least one reader who either lives there or has done so in the past.
(In case you don’t want to click through there, my example is about mentioning “a Tim Horton’s in Yellowknife,” only to have a reader email me to say that not only has he lived in Yellowknife, but he’s spent plenty of time at Tim Horton’s there.)
Anyway, let’s dive in? Here’s a link to the data again if you want to click through.
Or else, just think about where you live, and the people you know. Does it feel as if there’s been a “Great Resignation” going on around you? Or are you not at all surprised to learn that it’s different in other places? Let us know in the comments.
7 other things worth knowing today
Interesting article by my journalistic alma mater, Stars & Stripes, about a difficult job right now at the high levels of the U.S. military: keeping lines of communication open with their Russian counterparts so that the United States and its 29 allied nations in NATO don’t accidentally wind up in a shooting war with Russia over a mistake—say an errant missile hitting NATO territory. (Stars & Stripes)
Amid a growing consensus that Russia's invasion of Ukraine is morphing into a bloody stalemate that could last months, Ukrainian officials blamed the Kremlin for bombing an art school in the embattled port city of Mariupol where hundreds had taken shelter. Ukrainian officials also accused Russian forces of seizing and deporting several thousand Mariupol residents against their will to "remote cities in Russia." (LA Times)
A Russian oligarch’s yacht remains stuck in Norway because nobody will agree to sell it fuel. (Fox News)
Confirmation hearings begin today for Ketanji Brown Jackson, President Biden’s first nominee to the Supreme Court. They’re scheduled to run through Thursday. Separately, Justice Clarence Thomas, 73, has been hospitalized with flu-like symptoms since Friday. He’s expected to recover, but will miss some oral arguments. (WashPost, NBC News)
A Scottish judge is refusing to extradite a local teenager to Texas, where he’s charged with shooting a security guard at a fraternity party, on the grounds that Texas prisons are so bad that sending him there would be an international human rights violation. (The Marshall Project)
A professor sued his class, after he realized that one of his students had uploaded his old tests and exams to a website that charges students to get access to materials. He says the goal isn’t necessarily monetary damages, but the ability to issue a subpoena to the website and identify the student or students who shared his teaching materials. (NYT, it’s behind a paywall normally but I used the gift function; please let me know if this works!)
“Why do you want to close a Chick-fil-A?” Officials in Santa Barbara, California are considering declaring the city's only Chick-fil-A restaurant a "public nuisance" and banning its drive-thru due to the huge lines that snake around the block. (Insider)
Thanks for reading. Photo credit: Oh, just a screenshot from Google Maps. Want to see all my mistakes? Click here.
I have very much been a part of the great resignation. I left a job as an independent contractor medical summary clerk for a law firm in August 2021 as my request to be given employee status was denied and what I felt was poor treatment. I worked like an employee but was paid as a contractor. Try and fight a law firm on that. Ya, right!
I went on to work as an administrative assistant in an arts and recreation centre, a job I thought would have been a better fit for me. Nope. Some methods were simply too old school for my taste and some staff too snarky. I'm old enough to know what I want and that simply was not it, especially for the low pay. I really lost interest after getting my first paycheque really. Women have little power to negotiate good pay. I was told I was offered the top tier. Trust me, that was not saying much.
I moved on to work as a pharmacy technician, a job I also felt I would have been well suited for. I probably am, just was not the right work environment for me, again, some (not all) snarky and unsupportive staff, poor working conditions (barely time for a half-hour lunch, forget about any breaks), pay too low for responsibilities involved, and sexist treatment on the part of the pharmacist owner.
I did some housecleaning while looking for yet another job. I truly did not mind that, though I did mind waiting for my pay. Geez. Never in my life had I had to wait for pay like I did working for a housecleaning business. I was pretty shocked. I actually used to use the service once a month in the past. Knowing what I know now, if I want housekeeping services, I will look elsewhere knowing this company makes their staff wait for their money. I was thinking I was cursed there for a bit.
I then started a job as a bilingual French customer service agent for a call centre from home at the end of January. A few technological glitches at first, but now things are running very smoothly. I love using my voice to help people in my own little way. I often hear good comments from clients and coworkers about my work. That makes me feel good. When I can calm down an irate caller, it makes me feel good too, not always possible, but I do my best. My husband that sometimes works from home between service calls really finds that I am a natural at this role. He can't believe how well I'm doing. He was also very concerned as I really seemed to be having a real run of bad luck, but it appears as though my luck is changing.
A lesson here is try and try again to find the right fit for you. I trusted my gut and just left the positions where I felt treated poorly and managed to land a job that is a good fit for me after all.
The NYT link works! With the message: “ You have access to this article thanks to someone you know. Keep exploring The Times with a free account.”
Thank you!