Some things in life are timeless. For example, the traits of some of the best leaders applied centuries ago. (Example: Henry V?)
Also, it turns out — according to a new academic paper — the traits of some of the most horrible, ruthless, unethical, and psychopathic leaders are timeless, too.
Writing in the Asian Journal of Business Ethics, Clive Roland Boddy, an associate professor of management at Anglia Ruskin University in Cambridge, England, looked at two 17th-century leaders who faced the same extraordinary situation and achieved very different results.
The first: Jeronimus Cornelisz. He’s the bad one.
The second: Wiebbe Hayes. He’s the good one.
Context: In June 1629, a Dutch East India Company ship called the Batavia wrecked on a reef off what is now Western Australia. Some of the surviving officers sailed away to get help, leaving about 200 people stranded on a group of small islands.
That put Cornelisz, a company merchant manager, in charge of the left-behinds.
Now, Cornelisz wasn’t just a bad leader as in, “incompetent,” or “annoying.”
He was truly an evil person. We’re talking someone who almost immediately orchestrated the murders of roughly 100 survivors (supposedly to conserve scarce food and water), and was someone who thought nothing of committing sexual violence against women.
His ultimate plan was to seize the rescue ship when it returned and make off with the treasure aboard the Batavia.
So, he proceeded to consolidate power, replace members of his governing council with loyal supporters, and force others to swear allegiance to him.
Along the way, Cornelisz abandoned another group of survivors on a different island, and found their own leader: Hayes.
Hayes and his followers discovered fresh water and food, built defenses, and successfully resisted attacks by Cornelisz’s men.
When a rescue ship finally arrived, they managed to warn its crew about what had happened with the Cornelisz-led faction.
With that whole saga in mind, Cambridge’s Professor Boddy lined up Cornelisz’s behavior against a modern, 10-part measure of “corporate psychopathy.”
And according to his analysis, Cornelisz exhibited every single characteristic.
Here’s the list, condensed from a table in Boddy’s paper, along with the historical examples he used.
Superficial charm and apparent intelligence. Cornelisz was described as well-spoken and skilled at winning people over, particularly when he needed their support.
Untruthfulness and insincerity. He was a skilled liar who, even after his capture, tried to claim that he’d been forced to participate in the mutiny rather than having helped organize it.
Cheating personality. He tried to divide the men defending Hayes’s island by sending a letter falsely claiming that some of them were planning to betray the others.
Total egocentrism. Cornelisz promoted himself from under-merchant to Captain-General, complete with a new gold-trimmed uniform.
No remorse about harming others. He ordered the murders of men, women, and children, while keeping the best food, supplies, and treasure for himself.
Emotional shallowness. Cornelisz demanded personal oaths of allegiance from his followers but demonstrated no loyalty to them when he was eventually captured.
Unresponsiveness to personal interactions. Many examples, but one had to do with how he ignored the pleas of a captive woman who resisted his advances.
Refusal to take responsibility for actions. At his trial, he claimed that nothing that had happened was his fault.
Calmness, poise, and apparently rationity. Cornelisz presented mass murder as a perfectly logical solution to the problem of limited food and water supplies.
Lack of self-blame and self-insight. Even after the details of the killings emerged, he continued blaming dead colleagues for decisions he had made.
As Boddy described Cornelisz in the table, he “coldly, deliberately and calmly explained to his followers that murders were necessary to lower the number of dependants on the island.”
Obviously, this is extreme. But, Boddy’s point is that the methods Cornelisz used to accumulate and hold on to power are remarkably similar to those employed by some of the worst corporate leaders today.
As for Hayes and his group, having faced the same shipwreck and the same fundamental problem as Cornelisz (how to keep a group of stranded people alive until help arrived), they survived.
Boddy called the comparison a “natural experiment in leadership.”
One leader responded to the challenge by consolidating power, instilling fear, and killing people. The other got people working together, found resources, and saved lives.
If you’re looking for a lesson in leadership from this study, it’s probably pretty simple.
Take those 10 habits, and try to do the opposite.
Above all, don’t wind up featured in a scholarly article 400 years from now about what not to do.
Thank you for reading Understandably! If someone shared this with you, please sign up here for a free or paid subscription. I’m also grateful for one-off support (via Buy Me a Coffee) that helps me keep this whole thing going!
Other things worth knowing …
NYT: The United States has returned to a time, until recently unimaginable, when measles is a persistent threat, not just a sporadic one that can easily be snuffed out. Even with rigorous effort, it is likely to take years to regain measles elimination status, which the country officially lost on Tuesday. In the meantime, Americans will need to embrace strategies, some well worn and some new, to contend with this forgotten menace, more than a dozen experts said in interviews.
TechCrunch: The FBI is warning that hackers are relying on autonomous AI hacking tools to launch cyberattacks across the U.S. and globally. The campaigns include a widespread hack of customers of American IT company ConnectWise and across South Korea’s financial industry.
Newsweek: Hackers have planted malicious code on some of the world’s most popular websites, potentially exposing visitors to the theft of their personal and financial information, cybersecurity experts have warned. Researchers found at least 188 infected Optimizely projects across 178 organizations, including the BBC, CNN, Zoom, HSBC, Salesforce and Equifax.
Yahoo News: The Trump White House is starting to admit that your bank account and airline tickets are under attack from rogue AI.
Axios: The White House is dropping Heidi Overton’s nomination to lead the Food and Drug Administration because of a lack of congressional support. Overton, a physician and deputy director of the White House Domestic Policy Council, was nominated by President Trump in August.
Yahoo News: After flipping several key state legislatures and gubernatorial seats in this month’s elections, Democrats now have a path to nullify an institution of U.S. elections that has cost the party at least two presidential contests so far this century: the Electoral College. It could effectively be neutralized if enough states join a pledge known as the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
NPR: These birds fly 17,000 miles every year. Climate change could make it harder. “Shorebirds are ... miraculous migrants that travel these huge distances by these crazy adaptations,” says Rick Lanctot, a wildlife biologist with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
Thanks for reading. Photo by Alonso Reyes on Unsplash. I wrote about some of this at Inc.com. See you in the comments!

Cornelisz sounds just like our potus